The Chiropractic Board of Australia has had enough:
“We will not tolerate registered chiropractors giving misleading or unbalanced advice to patients, or providing advice or care that is not in the patient’s best interests,” chairman Phillip Donato said.
Dr Donato said chiropractors should only provide evidence-based treatment and anyone with concerns should report them. [Sydney Morning Herald August 9 2013]
Mr David Cahill is the business owner at Cahill Chiropractic, in Melbourne. He is a former board member of the Australian Spinal Research Foundation, and at one time he was even the president of the ASRF. From his business site:
Only two days ago, Cahill issued a direct challenge to the Chiropractic Board of Australia, on his Facebook page. In a startling display of misplaced hubris he prodded at the CBA with a Tomljenovic quote which is, of course, untrue:
“In the Western world cervical cancer is a rare disease with mortality rates that are several times lower than the rate of reported serious adverse reactions (including deaths) from HPV vaccination.” Human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine policy and evidence-based medicine: Are they at odds? Tomljenovic, L: Annals of Medicine, Volume 45, Number 2, March 2013, pp. 182-193(12)
With that quote I may have attracted your attention, and indeed the attention of the Chiropractors Registration Board (Australia). The Board has issued a directive regarding chiropractors discussing the issue of vaccinations with their patients, and indeed in any public forum.
He goes on to substantiate his anti-vaccine rhetoric, claiming that he and other chiropractors are more than capable of understanding the literature, by citing two more discredited articles by Tomljenovic and Shaw
And he rounded off the post with this:
The bottom line is that as each 12 year old girl that lines up to receive their vaccination, they are doing so based upon information that is NOT EVIDENCE-BASED, but rather, upon UNSUBSTANTIATED CLAIMS. Now does that sound familiar?
Of course it is not the job of the Chiropractors Registration Board to police the medical profession. There is a Medical Registration Board to do that. It appears they are unable to do so.
I, for one, cannot sit idly by and not relate these issues to my patients. I will do it quoting from the literature. I will ALWAYS have my patient’s best interests at heart, and I will never make unsubstantiated claims. I just wish others in the healthcare arena could hold their hand on their heart and say the same thing.
Okay. Again, here is why Cahill shouldn’t talk about vaccination, especially the HPV immunisation: Tired of HPV immunisation misinformation? Here’s a new published review.
And chiropractors, Messrs Pyke and Yeo thought Cahill’s screed was great:
So what else has Cahill got to offer on his business’s page?
The three reasons not to vaccinate, again, based on deliberate logical fallacies:
Gardasil hasn’t been linked to deaths, except when it has, but, then, it still isn’t safe, except when it is:
Vaccine safety and efficacy is just “dogma”. Extraordinary, yes, I know:
Because Mike Adams and his Natural News online shop are the go-to for peer-reviewed immunology and epidemiology.
Over to you, again, CBA.
Keep it coming Hank, just loving this l-o-n-g series. When will the CBA act? What are they waiting for? Surely they feel embarrassed that you are able to provide enough evidence to at least get them started.
Not good enough CBA. If the same applied for rogue Drs, and it was the AMA that needed to act, your members would be screaming foul.
You want to be taken seriously, get serious!
Idea for a study – compare & contrast suburb by suburb using the government’s available statistics, and compare & contrast against CBA’s register of practitioners, sorted by suburb. I wonder if there will be a correlation between areas with more chiropractors & lower immunisation rates?
But then again, association does not equal causation…
”I will never make unsubstantiated claims” says Cahill….ummmm….except (fingers crossed behind back):
”During pregnancy, a woman’s spine and pelvis undergo many changes and adaptations, and the risk of subluxation is increased. Consequently, the health and wellbeing of the growing baby may also be affected. ”
”The trip down the birth canal and out into a brand new world, while natural, can involve significant physical stress, resulting in subluxation. ”
”Maintaining a healthy spine and nervous system allows you the freedom to explore your true potential in life, and discover ways of living which enhance your life experience. ” (From website)
”When subluxations are adjusted, and more life flows between the brain and the body, the effects can sometimes be life-changing.” (FB page)
NEVER ever ever make unsubstantiated claims. Ever. Nope. You can’t make me.
Pingback: Anti-vaccine chiropractors 32 | reasonablehank
Pingback: The Congress of the Chiropractor – Dynamic Growth 2014 | reasonablehank
Pingback: Australian Spinal Research Foundation 2014 – time for a new shovel | reasonablehank