Anti-vaccine nurses and midwives 19

Aleena Noad is a registered nurse in Queensland. Her Facebook profile lists her profession and place of work, respectively, as “Critical Care Nurse” at “Gold Coast Hospital”:

Noad 1 profile critical care nurse at Gold Coast Hospital

Noad 9 AHPRA page

Noad shares public photos taken at her workplace, identifying her place of work:

Noad 7 nurse Gold Coast Health photo

Noad 13 work selfie

Noad also uses her profile to publish her anti-vaccination activism:

Noad 8 NJNP Brisbane June 2015 protest

Noad 10 not antivax meme profile

Noad is a member of three of the most prominent anti-vaccination Facebook groups:

Noad 22 AVA member redact

Noad 23 UA member

Noad 21 VFA member

Anti-Vaccination Australia posts.

On March 23 2016, Noad advised an anti-vaccination colleague to use anti-vaccination “ammo” the next time a vaccination discussion arises:

Noad 27 Kalina Martin party AVA OP March 23 2016

Noad 28 Kalina Martin party AVA

On February 11 2016, Noad posted a rabid antivax meme in response to another meme:

Noad 29 AVA OP Feb 2 2016 vax checkpoint

Noad 30 Feb 2 2016 AVA vax checkpoint

On February 1 2016, Noad proved her ineptitude concerning the routine HPV immunisation for boys:

Noad 31 AVA HPV Feb 1 2016 OP

Noad 32 AVA HPV Feb 1 2016

On January 9 2016, Noad applauded an antivax colleague for refusing Hepatitis B immunisation and Vitamin K for her brand new baby:

NOad 17 AVA OP January 9 2016 Perrin anti Vit K newborn in hsopital

NOad 18 AVA Perrin hospital Vit K well done mumma Jan 9 2016

On January 3 and 4 2016, Noad shared these anti-vaccination flyers – created by Queensland conspiracy theorist, David Fenton – and joined in her colleagues’ plans for an anti-vaccination letterbox-drop campaign:

Noad 1 AVA letterbox

NOad 2 AVA letterbox

Noad 3 AVA letterbox

Noad 4 AVA letterbox

Noad 5 AVA letterbox

Supporting comments from the post:

Noad 15 AVA letterbox

Noad 16 AVA letterbow share photos okay

Unvaccinated Australia posts.

On February 17 2016, Noad cited her qualifications in support of anti-vaccination activist and deregistered enrolled nurse, Louisa Kenzig (Lulu Langford):

Noad 26 UA Feb 17 2016 agreeing with Kenzig

On January 15 2016,  Noad agreed that vaccines are a cause in an alleged increase in food allergies in the community:

Noad 33 UA Jan 15 2016 vaccines cause over active immunity

On December 8 2015, Noad suggested an antivax colleague should have abused a caller who was advocating for Gardasil immunisation:

Noad 34 UA Dec 8 2015 OP Gardasil for boys

Noad 35 UA Dec 8 2015 Gardasil for boys

On September 25 2015 – joining in with Meryl Dorey, the public officer of the rabid anti-vaccination pressure group, the Australian Vaccination-skeptics Network – Noad argued that she could not “think of anything worse for the immune system of a little one” than a catch-up immunisation schedule:

Noad 36 UA Sept 25 2015 boosters with Meryl Dorey OP

Noad 37 UA Sept 25 2015 boosters with Meryl Dorey

Vaccine Choice Australia posts (formerly Vaccine Free Australia).

On February 11 2016, Noad applauded an antivax colleague who refused her pregnancy whooping cough and influenza vaccines:

Noad 38 VCA Feb 11 2016 applauding refusal WC pregnancy booster

On January 29 2016, Noad scoffed at the seriousness of whooping cough infection in an unvaccinated child:

Noad 39 VCA Jan 29 2016 laughing about WC infections

On January 24 2016, Noad diagnosed and offered treatment for an anti-vaccination colleague’s inflamed tonsils:

Noad 40 VCA Jan 24 2016 tonsils medical advice OP

Noad 41 VCA Jan 24 2016 tonsils med advice

On January 24 2016, Noad boasted of her successful, public anti-vaccination activism involving her mother-in-law:

Noad 42 VCA January 23 2016 antivax protest MIL OP

Noad 43 VCA Jan 24 2016 MIL antivax protest

On January 24 2016, Noad stated that she would be “praying for” a colleague’s friend who was to receive the MMR vaccine, whilst showing her ignorance in promoting the “shedding” myth:

Noad 44 VCA January 24 2016 praying for MMR booster recipient

On January 19 2016, Noad denigrated her hospital colleagues whom she claimed are always sick due to being immunised:

Noad 45 VCA Jan 17 2016 hospital always sick OP

Noad 46 VCA January 19 2016 hospital always sick

On December 18 2015, Noad commented in support of a “pox party”:

Noad 47 VCA Jan 18 2016 pox party

On December 14 2015, Noad commented that she would “kill” her child-carers if they allowed a doctor to immunise her child, based only on her conspiratorial reading of a consent form:

Noad 48 VCA December 14 2015 daycare emergency form

On December 14 2015, Noad commented in support of chicken pox parties, whilst simultaneously denigrating the Australian Medical Association and underplaying the potential seriousness of chicken pox infection:

Noad 49 VCA December 14 2015 pox party AMA OP

Noad 50 VCA December 14 2015 AMA pox party

On December 5 2015, Noad argued against the provision of immunisation to developing countries, by charities:

Noad 51 VCA Dec 5 2015 UNICEF vax OP

Noad 52 VCA Dec 5 2015 UNICEF vax

On November 27 2015, Noad cited her qualifications to argue against antibiotics, vaccines, and other medications:

Noad 53 VCA November 27 2015 anti medicines OP

Noad 54 VCA November 27 2015 anti medicines RN

On November 24 2015, Noad commented in support of rabid anti-vaccination activist, Courtney Hebberman:

Noad 55 VCA November 23 2015 Hebberman antivax meme

On November 23 2015, Noad argued that an immunisation hand-out which explains anti-vaccination myths to pregnant women was a “bunch of bs”:

Noad 56 VCA November 23 2015 OP vax pamphlet

Noad 57 vax pamphlet 1

Noad 58 vax pamphlet 2

Noad 59 VCA Nov 23 2015 vax pamphlet bullshit

On November 17 2015, Noad cited a conspiracy theory that whooping cough outbreaks were “fake” and created to promote more pregnancy boosters:

Noad 60 Nov 17 2015 WC outbreaks fake

Noad 61 November 17 2015 WC outbreaks fake

On September 18 2015, Noad cited her profession and workplace setting to state clearly that she is anti-vaccine, and that she is an active anti-vaccination activist in the workplace:

Noad 65 VCA Sept 18 2015 antivax nurse OP

Noad 66 VCA Sept 18 2015 antivax RN

On July 6 2015, Noad cited her profession in diagnosing an antivax colleague, and referring them to a natural health college:

Noad 72 VCA July 6 2015 nurse identified

On June 10 2015, Noad – an Australian registered health practitioner – asked her anti-vaccination colleagues, in an antivax group, for diphtheria immunisation information:

Noad 64 June 10 2015 does diphteria vax shed

On April 19 2015, Noad cited her profession in garnering support, from her antivax colleagues for her antivax beliefs:

Noad 70 VCA April 19 2015 antivaxers deluded OP

Noad 71 VCA April 19 2015 antivax resolve RN

Tamborine Mountain Community posts (not an anti-vaccination group, obviously).

Noad is a member of this Facebook group belonging to her local community:

Noad 69 TMC group member

On April 21 2016 – supporting comments from her anti-vaccination colleague, Kerry Baker – Noad inferred that eating a healthy, wholefood diet is preferable to an influenza immunisation, as promoted by a local doctor:

Noad 67 TMC April 24 2016 OP

Noad 68 TMC April 24 2016 Baker flu

The following addenda contain excerpts from the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia’s competency standards, codes, guidelines, and social media policy from which readers may wish to choose when lodging any complaint regarding the anti-vaccination activism of Aleena Noad.

Thanks for reading.

_________________________________

Addendum 1

National competency standards for the registered nurse (PDF)

Professional practice

Relates to the professional, legal and ethical responsibilities which require demonstration of a satisfactory knowledge base, accountability for practice, functioning in accordance with legislation affecting nursing and health care, and the protection of individual and group rights.

1 Practises in accordance with legislation affecting nursing practice and health care

1.1 Complies with relevant legislation and common law

1.2 Fulfils the duty of care

1.3 Recognises and responds appropriately to unsafe or unprofessional practice

2 Practises within a professional and ethical nursing framework

2.1 Practises in accordance with the nursing profession’s codes of ethics and conduct

2.2 Integrates organisational policies and guidelines with professional standards

2.3 Practises in a way that acknowledges the dignity, culture, values, beliefs and rights of individuals/groups

2.4 Advocates for individuals/groups and their rights for nursing and health care within organisational and management structures

2.5 Understands and practises within own scope of practice

2.6 Integrates nursing and health care knowledge, skills and attitudes to provide safe and effective nursing care

2.7 Recognises the differences in accountability and responsibility between registered nurses, enrolled nurses and unlicensed care workers

Critical thinking and analysis

Relates to self-appraisal, professional development and the value of evidence and research for practice. Reflecting on practice, feelings and beliefs and the consequences of these for individuals/ groups is an important professional bench- mark.

3 Practises within an evidence-based framework

3.1 Identifies the relevance of research to improving individual/group health outcomes

3.2 Uses best available evidence, nursing expertise and respect for the values and beliefs of individuals/groups in the provision of nursing care

3.3 Demonstrates analytical skills in accessing and evaluating health information and research evidence

3.4 Supports and contributes to nursing and health care research

3.5 Participates in quality improvement activities

4 Participates in ongoing professional development of self and others

4.1 Uses best available evidence, standards and guidelines to evaluate nursing performance:

4.2 Participates in professional development to enhance nursing practice

4.3 Contributes to the professional development of others

4.4 Uses appropriate strategies to manage own responses to the professional work environment

Provision and coordination of care

Relates to the coordination, organisation and provision of nursing care that includes the assessment of individuals/ groups, planning, implementation and evaluation of care.

5 Conducts a comprehensive and systematic nursing assessment

5.1 Uses a relevant evidence-based assessment framework to collect data about the physical socio-cultural and mental health of the individual/group

5.2 Uses a range of assessment techniques to collect relevant and accurate data

5.3 Analyses and interprets assessment data accurately

6 Plans nursing care in consultation with individuals/groups, significant others and the interdisciplinary health care team

6.1 Determines agreed priorities for resolving health needs of individuals/groups:

6.2 Identifies expected and agreed individual/group health outcomes including a time frame for achievement

6.3 Documents a plan of care to achieve expected outcomes

6.4 Plans for continuity of care to achieve expected outcomes

7 Provides comprehensive, safe and effective evidence-based nursing care to achieve identified individual/group health outcomes

7.1 Effectively manages the nursing care of individuals/groups

7.2 Provides nursing care according to the documented care or treatment plan

7.3 Prioritises workload based on the individual/group’s needs, acuity and optimal time for intervention

7.4 Responds effectively to unexpected or rapidly changing situations

7.5 Delegates aspects of care to others according to their competence and scope of practice

7.6 Provides effective and timely direction and supervision to ensure that delegated care is provided safely and accurately

7.7 Educates individuals/groups to promote independence and control over their health

8 Evaluates progress towards expected individual/group health outcomes in consultation with individuals/groups, significant others and interdisciplinary health care team

8.1 Determines progress of individuals/groups toward planned outcomes

8.2 Revises the plan of care and determines further outcomes in accordance with evaluation data

Collaborative and therapeutic practice

Relates to establishing, sustaining and concluding professional relationships with individuals/groups. This also contains those competencies that relate to nurses understanding their contribution to the interdisciplinary health care team.

9 Establishes, maintains and appropriately concludes therapeutic relationships

9.1 Establishes therapeutic relationships that are goal directed and recognises professional boundaries

9.2 Communicates effectively with individuals/groups to facilitate provision of care

9.3 Uses appropriate strategies to promote an individual’s/group’s self-esteem, dignity, integrity and

9.4 Assists and supports individuals/groups to make informed health care decisions

9.5 Facilitates a physical, psychosocial, cultural and spiritual environment that promotes individual/group safety and security

10 Collaborates with the interdisciplinary health care team to provide comprehensive nursing care

10.1 Recognises that the membership and roles of health care teams and service providers will vary depending on an individual’s/group’s needs and health care setting

10.2 Communicates nursing assessments and decisions to the interdisciplinary health care team and other relevant service providers

10.3 Facilitates coordination of care to achieve agreed health outcomes

10.4 Collaborates with the health care team to inform policy and guideline development

________________________________

Addendum 2

Nursing and Midwifery Board of Australia Codes and Guidelines.

Code of Professional Conduct for Nurses in Australia

1 Nurses practise in a safe and competent manner.

2 Nurses practise in accordance with the standards of the profession and broader health system.

Conduct Statement 2

Nurses practise in accordance with the standards of the profession and broader health system

Explanation

1 Nurses are responsible for ensuring the standard of their practice conforms to professional standards developed and agreed by the profession, with the object of enhancing the safety of people in their care as well as their partners, family members and other members of the person’s nominated network. This responsibility also applies to the nurses’ colleagues.

2 Nurses practise in accordance with wider standards relating to safety and quality in health care and accountability for a safe health system, such as those relating to health documentation and information management, incident reporting and participation in adverse event analysis and formal open disclosure procedures.

3 Nurses practise and conduct themselves in accordance with laws relevant to the profession and practice of nursing.

Conduct Statement 3

Nurses practise and conduct themselves in accordance with laws relevant to the profession and practice of nursing

Explanation

1 Nurses are familiar with relevant laws and ensure they do not engage in clinical or other practices prohibited by such laws or delegate to others activities prohibited by those laws.

2 Nurses witnessing the unlawful conduct of colleagues and other co-workers, whether in clinical, management, education or research areas of practice, have both a responsibility and an obligation to report such conduct to an appropriate authority and take other appropriate action as necessary to safeguard people and the public interest.

4 Nurses respect the dignity, culture, ethnicity, values and beliefs of people receiving care and treatment, and of their colleagues.

5 Nurses treat personal information obtained in a professional capacity as private and confidential.

6 Nurses provide impartial, honest and accurate information in relation to nursing care and health care products.

Conduct Statement 6

Nurses provide impartial, honest and accurate information in relation to nursing care and health care products

Explanation

1 When nurses provide advice about any care or product, they fully explain the advantages and disadvantages of alternative care or products so individuals can make informed choices. Nurses refrain from engaging in exploitation, misinformation or misrepresentation with regard to health care products and nursing care.

2 Nurses accurately represent the nature of their services or the care they intend to provide.

3 Where a specific care or a specific product is advised, nurses ensure their advice is based on adequate knowledge and not on commercial or other forms of gain. Deceptive endorsement of products or services or receipt of remuneration for products or services primarily for personal gain, other than remuneration in the course of a proper commercial relationship, is improper.

7 Nurses support the health, wellbeing and informed decision-making of people requiring or receiving care.

8 Nurses promote and preserve the trust and privilege inherent in the relationship between nurses and people receiving care.

Conduct Statement 8

Nurses promote and preserve the trust and privilege inherent in the relationship between nurses and people receiving care

Explanation

1 An inherent power imbalance exists within the relationship between people receiving care and nurses that may make the persons in their care vulnerable and open to exploitation. Nurses actively preserve the dignity of people through practised kindness and respect for the vulnerability and powerlessness of people in their care. Significant vulnerability and powerlessness can arise from the experience of illness and the need to engage with the health care system. The power relativities between a person and a nurse can be significant, particularly where the person has limited knowledge; experiences pain and illness; needs assistance with personal care; belongs to a marginalised group; or experiences an unfamiliar loss of self-determination. This vulnerability creates a power differential in the relationship between nurses and persons in their care that must be recognised and managed.

4 Nurses fulfil roles outside the professional role, including those as family members, friends and community members. Nurses are aware that dual relationships may compromise care outcomes and always conduct professional relationships with the primary intent of benefit for the person receiving care. Nurses take care when giving professional advice to people with whom they have a dual relationship (e.g. a family member or friend) and advise them to seek independent advice due to the existence of actual or potential conflicts of interest.

9 Nurses maintain and build on the community’s trust and confidence in the nursing profession.

Conduct Statement 9

Nurses maintain and build on the community’s trust and confidence in the nursing profession

Explanation

1 The conduct of nurses maintains and builds public trust and confidence in the profession at all times.

2 The unlawful and unethical actions of nurses in their personal lives risk adversely affecting both their own and the profession’s good reputation and standing in the eyes of the public. If the good standing of either individual nurses or the profession were to diminish, this might jeopardise the inherent trust between the nursing profession and the public necessary for effective therapeutic relationships and the effective delivery of nursing care.

3 Nurses consider the ethical interests of the nursing profession and the community when exercising their right to freedom of speech and participating in public, political and academic debate, including publication.

10 Nurses practise nursing reflectively and ethically.

Conduct Statement 10

Nurses practise nursing reflectively and ethically

Explanation

1 Nurses practise nursing reflectively and ethically, in accordance with the Code of Ethics for Nurses in Australia, in order to learn from experience and contribute to personal and professional practice.

2 Nurses develop and maintain appropriate and current quality nursing advice, support and care for each person requiring and receiving care and their partners, families and other members of their nominated social network. This responsibility also applies to colleagues of nurses.

3 Nurses evaluate their conduct and competency according to the standards of the nursing profession.

4 Nurses contribute to the professional development of students and colleagues.

5 Nurses participating in research do so in accordance with recognised research guidelines and do not violate their duty of care to persons receiving nursing care.

6 Nurses advise employers and any persons in their care of any reduction in their capacity to practise due to health, social or other factors, while they seek ways of redressing the problem.

_____________________________________

Code of Ethics for Nurses in Australia

1 Nurses value quality nursing care for all people.

2 Nurses value respect and kindness for self and others.

3 Nurses value the diversity of people.

4 Nurses value access to quality nursing and health care for all people.

5 Nurses value informed decision-making.

Value Statement 5

Nurses value informed decision-making

Explanation

Nurses value people’s interests in making free and informed decisions. This includes people having the opportunity to verify the meaning and implication of information being given to them when making decisions about their nursing and health care. Nurses also recognise that making decisions is sometimes constrained by circumstances beyond individual control and that there may be circumstances where informed decision making cannot always be fully realised.

1 Self: Nurses make informed decisions in relation to their practice within the constraints of their professional role and in accordance with ethical and legal requirements. Nurses are entitled to do this without undue pressure or coercion of any kind. Nurses are responsible for ensuring their decision-making is based on contemporary, relevant and well-founded knowledge and information.

2 Person (health consumer): Nurses value the legal and moral right of people, including children, to participate whenever possible in decision-making concerning their nursing and health care and treatment, and assist them to determine their care on the basis of informed decision making. This may involve ensuring people who do not speak English have access to a qualified health interpreter. Nurses recognise and respect the rights of people to engage in shared decision-making when consenting to care and treatment. Nurses also value the contribution made by persons whose decision-making may be restricted because of incapacity, disability or other factors, including legal constraints. Nurses are knowledgeable about such circumstances and in facilitating the role of family members, partners, friends and others in contributing to decision-making processes.

3 Colleagues: Nurses respect the rights of colleagues and members of other disciplines to participate in informed decision-making. Making these collaborative and informed decisions includes involving the person requiring or receiving nursing care (or their representative) in decisions relating to their nursing or health care, without being subject to coercion of any kind.

4 Community: Nurses value the contribution made by the community to nursing and health care decision-making through a range of activities, including consumer groups, advocacy and membership of health-related committees. Nurses also assist in keeping the community accurately informed on nursing and health-related issues.

6 Nurses value a culture of safety in nursing and health care.

Value Statement 6

Nurses value a culture of safety in nursing and health care

Explanation

Valuing a culture of safety involves nurses actively engaging in the development of shared knowledge and understanding of the crucial importance of safety in contemporary health care. Nurses who value a culture of safety appreciate that safety is everyone’s responsibility. Nurses support the development of risk management processes and a practice environment designed to reduce the incidence and impact of preventable adverse events in health care. Nurses also support the open disclosure of any adverse events to any person affected during the course of their care.

1 Self: Nurses value safe practice and a safe working environment; practise within the limitations of their knowledge and skills; and recognise and avoid situations where their ability to deliver quality care may be impaired. Nurses have a moral and legal right to practise in a safe environment, without fear for their own safety or that of others, and they seek remedies through accepted channels, including legal action, when this is not the case. Nurses value the maintenance of competence in contributing to a safe care and practice environment.

2 Person (health consumer): Nurses recognise that people are vulnerable to injuries and illnesses as a result of preventable human error and adverse events while in health care settings. Nurses play a key role in the detection and prevention of errors and adverse events in health care settings, and support and participate in systems to identify circumstances where people are at risk of harm. Nurses act to prevent or control such risks through prevention, monitoring, early identification and early management of adverse events. Nurses contribute to the confidential reporting of adverse events and errors, and to organisational processes for the open disclosure of these events to persons affected during the course of their care.

3 Colleagues: Nurses work with their colleagues to create a culture of safety. Nurses support the development of safer health care systems through non-punitive human error, adverse event management and related education. Nurses value the critical relationship between consumer safety and interprofessional competencies, including trustful communication, teamwork and situation awareness. Nurses view the detection of their own errors and risks or those of their colleagues as opportunities for achieving a safer health care system.

4 Community: Nurses, acting through their professional and industrial organisations and other appropriate authorities, participate in developing and improving the safety and quality of health care services for all people. This includes actively promoting the provision of equitable, just and culturally and socially responsive health care services for all people living, or seeking residence or asylum, in Australia. It also involves raising public awareness about the nature and importance of consumer safety programs in health care services.

7 Nurses value ethical management of information.

8 Nurses value a socially, economically and ecologically sustainable environment promoting health and wellbeing.

________________________________________

Addendum 3

Social Media Policy

When using social media, health practitioners should remember that the National Law, their National Board’s code of ethics and professional conduct (the Code of conduct) and the Guidelines for advertising regulated health services (the Advertising guidelines) apply.

Registered health practitioners should only post information that is not in breach of these obligations by:

  • complying with professional obligations
  • complying with confidentiality and privacy obligations (such as by not discussing patients or posting pictures of procedures, case studies, patients, or sensitive material which may enable patients to be identified without having obtained consent in appropriate situations)
  • presenting information in an unbiased, evidence-based context, and
  • not making unsubstantiated claims.

Additional information may be available from professional bodies and/or employers, which aims to support health practitioners’ use of social media. However, the legal, ethical, and professional obligations that registered health practitioners must adhere to are set out in the National Boards’ respective Code of conduct and the Advertising guidelines.

___________________________________________

About reasonable hank

I’m reasonable, mostly.

This entry was posted in anti-vaccination, anti-vaccination dishonesty, australian vaccination network, AVN, hospitals, Immunisation, meryl dorey, nurse, public health, skeptic, stop the australian vaccination network, vaccination, Vitamin K and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Anti-vaccine nurses and midwives 19

  1. Rhianna Miles says:

    I always struggle to understand why people who denigrate a Western medical approach so much choose to work within the same system they despise? I wonder how she goes administering the medications in ICU, if she considers the companies that make them corrupt?

    • GiJoel says:

      Double think is amazing. It’s the infected tonsil one that really tweaked me. Begging for advice so that she doesn’t have to go to a doctor, who would probably cure it in a week with either antibiotics, or surgery.

  2. Ex-Sheepie says:

    Ugh. This is my local hospital. Keep up the good work. Good to have names and faces. We shouldn’t have to put up with this kind of nut job working in our hospitals. Why doesn’t she get a job healing the critically injured in a homeopathic hospital with potato poultices? Oh that’s right, because it doesn’t exist!

  3. @advodiaboli says:

    Wow. “Great. Thanks for enlightening me on that”, is Noad’s response to the revelation that “apparently males can contract HPV also”. Males are an important reservoir and infection vector with respect to HPV. And Noad is a registered nurse!
    Worse, that conservative, abstinence-laden rant advising Molly to have her son, “find a clean partner and practice monogamy” is demonstrably flawed. Like “The Silver Ring Thing” virginity pledge, this approach relies on intention and willpower alone. Follow up studies on pledges show little effect on STD rates and greater experimentation with oral & anal sex.
    If only time spent reading anti-vaccine rubbish was spent improving her working knowledge.
    Noad shouldn’t be advising anyone on health.

  4. Graham says:

    And to think all this started back in the 1990s when several lawyers looking at how easy it was to scaremonger people into mass class action suits (Silicone Breast Implants) decided to make a killing by pulling the same scam but using vaccines as a target.

    The lawyers are forgotten, but the harm they caused is never ending.

Leave a Reply