A Time to Kill: Meryl Dorey and her AVsN give medical advice on seizures.

After an extensive investigation into the Australian Vaccination skeptics Network, the NSW Health Care Complaints Commission issued a Public Health Warning on April 30 2014 [my bold]:

Public warning

The Commission has established that AVN does not provide reliable information in relation to certain vaccines and vaccination more generally. The Commission considers that AVN’s dissemination of misleading, misrepresented and incorrect information about vaccination engenders fear and alarm and is likely to detrimentally affect the clinical management or care of its readers.

Given the issues identified with the information disseminated by AVN, the Commission urges general caution is exercised when using AVN’s website or Facebook page to research vaccination and to consult other reliable sources, including speaking to a medical practitioner, to make an informed decision.

The Commission has recommended that AVN amend its published information with regard to the above issues and the Commission will monitor the implementation of these recommendations.

I know that the AVsN has not amended misinformation which states vaccines cause autism, as requested. We have no idea what monitoring is being undertaken by the HCCC. I know that Meryl Dorey and the AVsN have repeatedly breached the HCCC’s request to amend vaccines-cause-autism misinformation, as the AVsN’s public officer, Dorey, has continued to post the claim to the AVsN Facebook page.

Today, Dorey took it to another level. This act was outside the purview of the Public Warning, as that pertained to vaccination.

Today, Dorey was out to maim, or possibly even kill. Dorey knows the possible consequences of ceasing anti-convulsant medication as she is friends with parents whose toddler died because they ceased her medication in lieu of magic. They are featured in this article from The Age, in 2003:

The parents of a toddler who died after epileptic seizures could face criminal charges over her death after a coroner ruled they fundamentally breached their duty of care by not giving her anti-convulsant medication.

Coroner Phil Byrne said Warren and Helena Denley ignored specialist advice of Royal Children’s Hospital medical staff and were instead prepared to rely on various, ill-informed advice to help their daughter Isabella.

The inquest heard Mr and Mrs Denley had seen alternative therapists, including a psychic who said the seizures were related to a past-life trauma.

Isabella, 13 months, died at home in Kew on October 19 last year after 30 seizures in seven months…

…in a police statement tendered to the court, Mr Denley, an information technology contractor, said in the weeks before Isabella died, she was purely on homoeopathic medicine…

So, knowing of the real adverse events of dissuading patients from their life-saving medication, why would Meryl Dorey do precisely the same thing? She knows first hand that a little girl died because her parents, Dorey’s mates, turned to unproven therapies.

With the above in mind, here is Meryl Dorey providing medical advice, regarding seizures, at 0634 hours on August 31 2014:

AVN 6869 Dorey alt med for seizuresI can certainly think of one “natural alternative” for seizures, and I’m surprised Dorey couldn’t also: death. Death is the ultimate natural cure. Tried and true.

It is long past time the NSW HCCC issued a Prohibition Order against Dorey and her organisation.

Dorey and her organisation need to be shut down before they kill someone.

This can be a real outcome of the type of advice given by an untrained, unqualified, unregistered crackpot who has the hubris to think she knows more than a specialist:

What the harm Isabella DenleySource: What’s the Harm

Please lodge a complaint about Dorey’s behaviour – conducted as an official representative of the AVsN – to the NSW Health Care Complaints Commission, here.

Update September 1 2014

I wanted to include this comment from someone who knows the ups and downs of this topic (to put it mildly). There just isn’t anything like a smackdown from someone who really knows what they are talking about to put the dangerous advice of Meryl Dorey and her cabal into perspective. This comment comes from the Mamamia Facebook page, where an article on this very topic was posted today:

AVN 6870 MM thread epilepsy sufferer no meds ketogenic dietThank you Debbie Kurikka. On behalf of everyone who will benefit from your voice. Thank you.

Posted in abuse, anti-vaccination dishonesty, australian vaccination network, AVN, Health Care Complaints Commission, homeopathy, meryl dorey, skeptic, stop the australian vaccination network | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Updated: Why does NSW Fair Trading swallow the lies of the AVsN?

This will be a quick post. I had meant to write something about this months ago.

The Australian Vaccination Network was ordered to change its deceptive name in 2012. It appealed the order and lost that appeal in 2013. It was thenceforth to be known by the still deceptive – yet not as much – name, Australian Vaccination-skeptics Network.

The AVsN changed its name on many of its fora. It fought hard to weasel its way out of its obligations, with several reminders being sent to the AVsN to comply. It was extraordinary how the compliance checks needed to be carried out by citizens – who then notified the appropriate departments – and not the government departments charged with these tasks.

Since the enforcement of the name change came into place the AVsN have steadfastly tried everything to worm their way out of changing their Facebook page’s name. They know the Facebook page is the most accessed, and the most user-friendly for their task of disseminating anti-vaccination lies. Facebook is big for liars. It gets the most hits, and it casts the biggest net.

Astonishingly, New South Wales Fair Trading have accepted a monster of a lie from Meryl Dorey and her cabal: that being that the AVsN gave the Facebook page away, and that it is no longer owned by the AVsN. Here is an August 2014 letter from NSWFT to a complainant, stating precisely that:

AVN 6859 DFT letter name change

Anyway, I thought I would quickly check and screenshot two AVsN fora to show how easily NSWFT could have found out that the AVsN is lying. It must be noted in passing that the main Facebook page administrator using the AVN Facebook account a month ago was Meryl Dorey. And not only by a nose: Dorey was controlling the page, same as she ever was.

This is a screenshot of the AVsN’s official Twitter page. It was always the AVN’s official Twitter page, and it says as much in the descriptor:

AVN 6856 Twitter official pageThe official Twitter page was always linked to the AVN’s official Facebook page. Check out the timestamp for the vaccines-cause-autism lie in the screenshot.

Now, using this screenshot taken from the AVN Facebook page (immediately after), we see that precisely the same vaccines-cause-autism lie appears on the page. The timestamp is the same, even down to the minute:

AVN 6857 Facebook page timestamp sameChecking these two pages off against each other, and perusing the timestamps took less than twenty seconds. It is obvious that the AVsN is in control of both accounts – Twitter and Facebook – and that the claim that they no longer own the Facebook page is an outright lie put forward to deflect any further regulatory and disciplinary action which would surely come the AVsN’s way – continuing to breach orders against claims set out in the Public Health Warning is only one of the ongoing flagrant breaches carried out by Dorey and her cult. It is amazing that the very vaccines-cause-autism lie used above is, in itself, another breach of the findings set down by the NSW Health Care Complaints Commission in the Public Health Warning against the AVsN.

Getting back to the evidence for the claim by Dorey and her cult that the AVsN no longer own the page, I wonder out loud how the claim was tested by NSWFT. This is the AVN Facebook about page:

AVN 6858 about pageWe can see they still link to the all-important money-maker, the “AVN” shop, and the cashflow-sustaining “AVN membership”. And the page still links to the main AVN URL. They changed a couple of “us” and “we” into “them” and “they” as well. And the sockpuppet who now ‘owns’ the page has set up a gmail account as a contact (a contact which doesn’t issue replies). What other evidence is there that the AVsN, and Dorey, no longer control the Facebook page? This:

This page is owned by and managed by a long-time fan of the Australian Vaccination-skeptics Network but it is not the responsibility of that organization.


Company Overview

This page is owned by Ben Rush, a long-time fan of the Australian Vaccination-skeptics Network (AVN), Inc.

Stick a fork in me and turn me over I’m done.

This is an organisation which is practised at deception and non-compliance, callousness and cruelty. And NSW Fair Trading rolled over and said it was all too hard, and took the word of a cabal of anti-vaccinationists over a bit of digging. Twenty seconds work could have shown them the AVsN are lying, again. But it’s all just too hard.

And you know what makes it stink even more? Four months before the above NSWFT hand-wave, NSWFT notified another complainant that they had contacted Dorey, and that Dorey had advised NSWFT that the Facebook name would be changed:

AVN 6860 April letter from DFT DoreyThe Australian Vaccination-skeptics Network and its lead ideologue Meryl Dorey continue to lie to government departments such as NSWFT, and regulators such as the NSW HCCC; and yet here we are. Nothing has been done. The AVsN is still free to lie to parents, with nothing but disdain for those who should be holding them accountable.


Thanks very much to those who provided letters included above.

Update August 31 2014

I wanted to wait until the end of the month of August, which is now, to add this update. For some time since it became apparent that NSWFT had swallowed the lies of Meryl Dorey hook, line, and sinker, that neither she, nor her organisation – of which she is the public officer and landlord – are the owners of the “AVN” Facebook page, I have been meaning to manually count the original administrator posts on the AVN Facebook page. Well, I’ve counted the AVN admin posts.

The huge bulk of the Facebook posts are posted via the AVsN’s Hootsuite account. There is no point attempting to work out which liar with access posted from there. I’ve included the Hootsuite posts in my manual count; but, really, it might be all Dorey’s work on Hootsuite, or none of it might be Dorey. One thing is for sure, the Hootsuite account is an official AVsN account, even having once been linked to Dorey’s own Facebook profile. The Hootesuite account is indeed still linked to the AVsN sister page – where posts from Hootsuite are cloned – Seriously Concerned About Gardasil; or as I much prefer to call it, SCAG. As you can see, Dorey is still a SCAG admin, along with a vicious sockpuppet (Payne), and an AVN stalwart (MJ Vassallo). Missing, you will notice, is one Ben Rush:

AVN 6867 Dorey Payne admins of SCAGSo, back to our admin posts. I have created four tables to cover the last four months, which takes us back in time to the publication of the HCCC’s Public Warning against the AVsN (on April 30 2014).

I’ll let everyone work out the ratios for themselves. One thing which stands out like a beacon of truth: Meryl Dorey, the public officer of the Australian Vaccination skeptics Network, is the predominant Facebook page administrator. Indeed, the new “page owner”, *cough* Ben Rush (BR24), has made one post in four months. One. Post.

Here is August 2014:

AVN 6862 August admin postsHere is the table for July 2014:

AVN 6863 July admin postsHere is the table for June 2014:

AVN 6864 June admin postsAnd, here is the table for May 2014:

AVN 6865 May admin postsOver to you, New South Wales Fair Trading. Do you still believe the word of Meryl Dorey when she claims that someone else, a sockpuppet who has only one recorded post to its name in four months of manual counting, “owns” the AVN Facebook page (apart from Facebook, who owns the AVN Facebook page)?

This is almost into the realms of Yes, Minister.

Update September 23 2014

For those who have been following the incessant charade being played out by Dorey and the AVsN, I wanted to include this last excerpt from a NSW Fair Trading Association Extract, printed on July 31 2014, and obtained by Stop the Australian (anti) Vaccination Network.

This document clearly shows that Meryl Dorey is still the Public Officer of the AVsN; and by acting in this role, and on AVsN social media, she is also acting as an official spokesperson of the AVsN. Remember, Dorey is not operating on the AVsN’s Facebook page as “Meryl Dorey”; she is operating as “Australian Vaccination Network”. She is not operating on the AVsN’s Twitter account as “Meryl Dorey”; she is operating as “@nocompulsoryvac”:

AVN 6878 Meryl Dorey still Public Officer as of July 2014 Fair Trading statement

Posted in anti-vaccination dishonesty, australian vaccination network, AVN, meryl dorey, stop the australian vaccination network, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 8 Comments

Australian Spinal Research Foundation 2014 – time for a new shovel

Today, I was delighted to be reminded to visit the website of the Australian Spinal Research Foundation. I hadn’t been there for a while.

In October 2013 I wrote about the board of governors of the ASRF:  The Australian Spinal Research Foundation – the infection of anti-vaccinationismHere is a quick recap from my post:

The Australian Spinal Research Foundation is an associated organisation of the Chiropractors’ Association of Australia. The ASRF’s raison d’être is research. The main area of research would seem to be to prove that the chiropractic subluxation is a thing, which is a real thing, as opposed to the thing which currently exists only in the minds of fundamentalist chiropractors and their brainwashed customers. To do this research the ASRF holds charitable status. With great power comes great responsibility. I hope they are spending their earnings in the right places:

Our Bona Fides

Australian Spinal Research Foundation is a company limited by guarantee under Australian Corporations Law. The Foundation is an approved Deductible Gift Recipient (DGR) under the Australian Income Tax Assessment Act (Section 30-15, Research Institute) and an Income Tax Exempt Charity (Section 50-5). The Foundation is registered as Charity No. 1193 under the Queensland Collections Act and is exempt from Stamp Duty under the Stamp Act.

Only two days ago a blockbuster of a post was published by The Rogue Chiropractor:  Australian Spinal Research Foundation: it’s time to drop the pretence. It has been revealed that the research output of the ASRF is abysmal; and their research funding is even worse [my bold]:

The ASRF started in 1976 and is considered a well-established not-for-profit organisation. Over the past 13 years the ASRF has grossed an impressive $12.9M largely through spizzed-up promotion of subluxation theories. Only 6.9% of all revenue ends up eventuating in the ASRF’s primary function which is research grant activity. Of interest, 33.7% of income is spent on wages and salaries…

It is now 2013 and we must ask ourselves the question – are we any closer to being able to prove the existence of the vertebral subluxation complex and the effects they have on health? Twelve years on and we are still no closer to being able to accurately define a valid and reliable method of identifying one. Should the spizzed-up CAA board throw millions of dollars of their membership’s money at subluxation research based upon the advice of this floundering research foundation?

As you can see by the title of my 2013 post, my focus was on the make-up of the board members’ slant on immunisation, if known. From the conclusion of my post:

So, that is all eleven of the board of governors of the Australian Spinal Research Foundation. Only three of them have no anti-vaccine affiliation or online presence of anti-vaccine misinformation. Eight of these eleven people can be regarded as anti-vaccinationists. And five of those eight anti-vaccinationists are or were members of Australia’s most prominently, consistently wrong conglomerate of nutbag conspiracy theorists one could hesitantly regard as akin to health information providers. Five out of eleven of the board members of this charity, are or were members of the AVN.

Holy crap, you guys.

73% of the ASRF board is anti-vaccine. That’s almost a distinction.

And I didn’t even include the former ASRF board members who featured in my anti-vaccine series: David Cahill and Taylor Vagg. Nor did I include others, like Angus Pyke, and Billy Chow, who are not on the board; but, appear to be heavily involved in steering the organisation…

Well, it’s now 2014, and there’s a new board of governors in place. Gone from the old board are Ray Hayek, James Carter, Gary Smith, and Tony Rose. The board has shrunk from eleven members down to nine. To get back up to our new number, the new board members are – and you have just read these names above – Angus Pyke and Billy Chow.

The new board of the Australian Spinal Research Foundation is: Martin Harvey (antivax); Angus Pyke (antivax); Nimrod Weiner (antivax); Mark Uren (antivax); Carmen Atkinson (antivax); Billy Chow (anti-vax); Craig Foote (antivax); Ali Postles (antivax); and Professor Elizabeth Deane (not known; why, oh why are you on this board?).

Of the anti-vaccine chiropractors listed on the new board, four of them are/were members of the fundamentalist anti-vaccination pressure group, the Australian Vaccination (skeptics) Network. Four out of nine: that’s only 44%, right? That’s not too bad for a health charity, right?

Of the new board of the ASRF – a charity – eight of the nine board members are anti-vaccine: that’s right, 89% of the board of governors of the leading Australian chiropractic research organisation, which is a charity, is anti-vaccine. Now, say that three times and a subluxation appears.

Also of interest, two of those anti-vaccine board members – Uren and Chow – are also board members of the Chiropractors’ Association of Australia. That’s the national board; not one of those out-of-control state boards.

Again, wrap your heads around this:

There is a health charity in Australia, the ASRF, whose existence is predicated on the research of, and indeed the finding of, something which does not exist – the chiropractic vertebral subluxation. The board of governors of this charity is 89% anti-vaccine – up from a paltry 73% in 2013. They’ve gone from a mere distinction in anti-vaccinationism to a HD! Two of those anti-vaccine board members are also board members of Australia’s leading chiropractic representative organisation, the CAA.

And a great, big bulk of the Australian chiropractic profession is okay with this.

Here is what the other Australian chiropractic representative organisation (the evidence-based one), the Chiropractic and Osteopathic College of Australasia, says about the subluxation:

It is not supported by any clinical research evidence that would allow claims to be made that it is the cause of disease [as per General Chiropractic Council]

COCA 1 VSC statementAnd yet here we are, with an Australian charity, whose finances and research output have been questioned, which is run by anti-vaccinationists, researching the existence of winged dragons. And still none fly. Chiropractic: almost 120 years in existence, and there still be no flying dragons.

And here’s the kicker: these people advocate and practice the adjustment of babies, even just minutes and hours after birth, based on the existence of these winged dragons.

Posted in anti-vaccination dishonesty, australian vaccination network, AVN, chiropractic, meryl dorey, skeptic, stop the australian vaccination network | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 10 Comments

Chiropractors’ Association of Australia (NSW) brings in anti-vaccine subluxationist as lead seminar speaker

I get it. I really do. Over the last year the Chiropractors’ Association of Australia has been dragged kicking and screaming into the Age of Evidence. The other main chiropractic representative body, the Chiropractic and Osteopathic College of Australasia (COCA), is already there. Of their own accord COCA works industriously to ensure the evidence base for its profession is maintained. The CAA is acting because it doesn’t have a choice. Those high up know they are staring up from inside the S-bend, and they are fighting for the rim, with bloodied fingernails.

Only last year I wrote about the inclusion of anti-vaccine subluxationist Stephen Franson, and his role as the lead speaker at the CAA’s National Development Forum. The CAA president even put out a press release disclaiming Franson’s basic beliefs as not representative of his NDF subject matter.

So here we are again, almost one year later. The CAA NSW is holding its Annual General Meeting Seminar Weekend in one month. The lead speaker is Jeanne Ohm, a US chiropractor who first came to my attention whilst I was reading up on anti-vaccine chiropractors, for my series. In fact, Ohm first came into my field of vision as an anti-vaccine chiropractor.

Ohm is perceived in chiropractic circles as somewhat of an expert in the area of perinatal care: and this is the subject of her presentation at the CAA AGM:

Ohm 12 CAA NSW November 2014

I’m not going to focus too much on this subject, including the Webster Technique – as I believe others may cover that shortly – except to note that one of Ohm’s areas of expertise is the chiropractic/subluxationist invention of “birth trauma”:

It is her understanding that birth trauma is a current chiropractic concern, and  therefore it has become her goal to eliminate its damaging effects on the newborn

Of course it is a “chiropractic concern”. It is an invention based on the vitalism inherent in non evidence based chiropractic: it gives a chance for the chiropractor to start laying their hands on babies from birth, for no benefit, apart from the appeasement of the chiropractor’s soul. Subluxations begin before birth, you know. It’s magic. And it’s an income.

[Edit August 22 – this article on Webster Technique and more was published on The Conversation, authored by Dr Mick Vagg: Chiropractic care in pregnancy and childhood – a castle built on a swamp. It is mandatory reading] 

What I want to focus on, as is my wont, is the anti-vaccinationism of Jeanne Ohm. I have come to strongly believe that a person’s adherence to an ideology such as anti-vaccinationism is a very good indicator of the merit of anything else that particular person has to say. It’s a red flag. No, it’s more than that. It’s a red banner, daubed in Comic Sans, flying at the forefront of a column of Orcs. When someone can deny, in the face of the overwhelming literature, the benefits of something like immunisation, in lieu of their favourite ideologically driven beliefs, then, that person cannot be perceived to be able to think properly, or honestly. They have no place anywhere near mothers, babies, fathers, or computers.

Jeanne Ohm gives vaccination seminars at her business. Here is one from January 2014:

Ohm 14 immunisation seminar Jan 2014This is from the blog post linked by Ohm (she is one of the chief editors of Pathways to Family Wellness, the anti-vaccine, chiropractic magazine seen all over Facebook) [my bold]:

In another paper, Parental Fears Over Childhood Vaccination Must Be Addressed,  it is clear that the number of parents questioning the medical system is becoming a major concern. This is another whole topic in itself, but very briefly, do not make your choices from “fearing the effects of vaccines” make your choices from a confidence that the body’s immune system out-performs any vaccine. If you are not quite fully assured,  boost your confidence by realizing that the scientific literature does not substantiate many rhetorical recommendations for vaccinations. An interesting article published in Prevent Disease titled, “Nine Questions that Stump Every Pro-Vaccine Advocate and Their Claims” is listed below for your access.

You read that right. She cites that tragicomedy, Nine Questions, with a straight face. Ohm also cites the National Vaccine Information Center and Barbara Loe Fisher as if it’s a good thing:

Ohm 15 Pathways blog re immunisation seminarThere is another item I didn’t notice on her CAA CV; Ohm’s membership of the Help the Australian Vaccination Network Facebook group. I highly suggest having a look at the members list. There are many familiar chiropractic faces there:

Ohm 13 member of Help the AVNLooking at Ohm’s Facebook page gives a further insight into what makes this anti-vaccine subluxationist tick.  I wasn’t really aiming at kicking off with any Godwins, but, look, I wasn’t given any choice:

Ohm 1 nazi state vaccine exemptionsDeceptively, callously, and dishonestly Ohm claims a boy “died from the flu vaccine”. This lie has already been addressed by Liz Ditz and Orac:

Ohm 2 child died from flu vaccineLet’s break it up with some Scientology, the CCHR:

Ohm 3 CCHRHere’s a Pathways meme which indicates anti-vaccinationists are all about informing, which is really the opposite of what they do:

Ohm 4 parents that don't vaccinate memeThe anti-vaccine cacophony called The Refusers – DRINK:

Ohm 5 nurse fired flu shot The RefusersHere’s a anti-vaccine feature double. It’s Doctored, and The Greater Good:                           

Ohm 6 Doctored

Ohm 8 The Greater Good






The ever reliable Gaia Health also amazingly gets a run on this respected practitioner’s page:

Ohm 7 flu vaccine useless Gaia HealthOf course Ohm is just asking questions with this vaccines-cause-autism meme, a staple of any anti-vaccine page:

Ohm 9 antivax meme autismCiting that bastion of integrity, Prevent Disease, Ohm delights in dead pregnant women. That’s the logical conclusion of her glee:

Ohm 10 preventdisease women refusing flu shots

And what’s an anti-vaccine propagandist of the highest order without some Dr Paul Offit bashing? Citing The Refusers, again, no less:

Ohm 11 Offit bashing The RefusersI don’t have much more to say.

Does the CAA NSW have any notion of the term “due diligence”?

Does the CAA NSW realise that clawing its way out of the bowl entails more that just staying above the water line?

I and others really do applaud some CAA boards for doing their best against a tide of vitalistic resentment.  But, to be taken seriously means getting all the way out of the toilet.

Update same day

I had not noticed this image earlier. The callous and ignorant Rob Schneider tweet has itself caused internet fury over the last few days. The notoriously delusional anti-vaccine chiropractor, Billy DeMoss, shared it, adding his own insane capslock musings. That’s pretty bad.

Jeanne Ohm ‘liked’ it. She sure is a fine choice for the CAA NSW to headline their event. I don’t even have the energy to swear. The CAA is a joke:

Ohm 16 liked DeMoss Schneider post Robin Williams

Posted in anti-vaccination dishonesty, chiropractic, skeptic | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 7 Comments

Anti-vaccine chiropractors redux 4

Just over one year ago, on August 8 2013, the Chiropractic Board of Australia issued a directive to all chiropractors. From the media release [bold mine]:

The Chiropractic Board of Australia cracks down to protect the public.

The Chiropractic Board of Australia is cracking down on chiropractors who step outside their primary role as healthcare practitioners and provide treatment that puts the public at risk.

To protect public safety, the Board has:

- ordered practitioners to remove all anti-vaccination material from their websites and clinics
– removed several courses from the list of approved CPD programs, and
– introduced random audits of practitioner compliance with the Board’s registration standards.


’However, the Board takes a very strong view of any practitioner who makes unsubstantiated claims about treatment which is not supported within an evidence-based context,’ he said.

We will not tolerate registered chiropractors giving misleading or unbalanced advice to patients, or providing advice or care that is not in the patient’s best interests.’

I deliberately state the date on which the CBA released that press release, as I had to draw a line at which I would stop looking at today’s anti-vaccine chiropractor. Life is just too short. And it marks the cut-off day when all chiropractors should damn well know better.

HIH 20 April Traynor picApril Traynor runs a manipulation business called Hands in Health Wollongong, in NSW. She is/was a member of the anti-vaccination pressure group, the Australian Vaccination (skeptics) Network (AVSN).

Up first we have a lie. Who’d have guessed? A “typical” influenza vaccine contains no mercury, but, this doesn’t stop the AVSN – Traynor’s source – from lying about it:

HIH 1 AVN flu shot mercuryNext up we have one of our old favourite anti-vaccine memes, ‘why are my kids a threat to yours?':

HIH 2 unvaccinated kids memeTraynor shares another anti-vaccine meme from the AVSN, this time using the “r” word. I do no think it means what you think it means:

HIH 3 AVN non vax memeThe German homeopath’s survey of anti-vaccinationists. Traynor liked this one so much she shared it twice; astonishingly, the first time on the very day the CBA issued its directive:

HIH 33 500% unvaxed healthy twice

Traynor also gives us the obligatory Natural News article of “outrageous facts” about vaccines:

HIH 5 Nat News vaccine factsAnother AVSN share, this time it’s the Meryl Dorey petition based on anti-vaccine misinformation:

HIH 6 AVN petitionI was losing hope, but, Traynor came up with the goods, sharing another AVSN post about the mandatory anti-vaccine lie that vaccines cause autism:

HIH 7 AVN vaccines cause autismMoving on to other topics, Traynor gives us some cancer cure misinformation, the type of which is the lowest of the low of false hopes pedaled for money:

HIH 9 cancer baking sodaLike any good chiropractic vitalist Traynor raises the kids’ ear infections, as if chiropractic has been shown to be effective or something (it hasn’t, and Murdoch University agrees):

HIH 10 chiro ear infections kidsI love this one. Nothing really to say. This one only needs a meme of that little chubby bubbles girl running for her life, from a microwave:

HIH 12 microwavesAnd next we have an example – well, four, really – of one of the greatest pieces of misinformation used by vitalistic chiropractors worldwide: the **% immune boosting properties of getting an adjustment. It is rubbish, and Murdoch University agrees:

HIH 34 200% immune boost x 4 2013 2014

Any chiropractic organisation, teaching facility, or practitioner worth their salt now regards the chiropractic, or vertebral, subluxation as a theoretical, historical concept. It exists in the minds of the believers. And there are plenty out there. Watch out for that “loss of health”:

HIH 15 subluxations loss of healthSubluxations are also invisible on imaging. So, always, these aren’t the subluxations you’re looking for:

HIH 16 subluxation yodaWhen we have a look at Traynor’s business website things are only slightly better. Still not good. But not as bad.

Traynor links to anti-vaccine sites the AVSN, and The Greater Good. She also links to cancer cure crankery such as The Wellness Warrior, and Cancer the Forbidden Cure; as well as many other links of ill-repute:

HIH 18 web links AVN Greater Good Cancer cure scamTraynor also links to the anti-vaccine book written by anti-vaccine chiropractor Warren Sipser, board member of the Chiropractors’ Association of Australia – Victoria. I previously covered Sipser’s book, here:

HIH 19 web rec reading Sipser bookI only wanted to cover one more topic, and it’s a big problem in Australian chiropractic. It seems that there is still so much bravado present that these chiropractors don’t care if they are in breach or not. We’re talking about testimonials. Here is Traynor’s Facebook page, again:

HIH 21 testimonialsAnd here is one written by New Zealand anti-vaccine chiropractor and dog-adjuster, Sheridan Kay:

HIH 22 testimonial KayThis is the recently updated National Law – Guidelines for advertising regulated health services. Compare what it stipulates, as opposed to what knowingly appears on Traynor’s Facebook page:

6.2.3 Testimonials

Section 133 of the National Law states:

  1. A person must not advertise a regulated health service, or a business that provides a regulated health service, in a way that –
    1. Uses testimonials or purported testimonials about the service or business

The National Law does not define ‘testimonial’, so the word has its ordinary meaning of a positive statement about a person or thing. In the context of the National Law, a testimonial includes recommendations, or statements about the clinical aspects of a regulated health service.

The National Law ban on using testimonials means it is not acceptable to use testimonials in your own advertising, such as on your Facebook page, in a print, radio or television advertisement, or on your website. This means that::

  1. you cannot use or quote testimonials on a site or in social media that is advertising a regulated health service, including patients posting comments about a practitioner on the practitioner’s business website, and
  2. you cannot use testimonials in advertising a regulated health service to promote a practitioner or service.

Health practitioners should therefore not encourage patients to leave testimonials on websites health practitioners control that advertise their own regulated health services, and should remove any testimonials that are posted there.

Hopefully the CBA can have a look at this chiropractor’s behaviour and make appropriate findings. We’re not hearing much in regards to meaningful action against rogue practitioners. We need to hear more about what is being done.

Obi Wan


Much thanks to Wallace for pointing out this chiropractor’s website. 

Update August 28 2014

Traynor obviously has no intention of ceasing her anti-vaccine campaign, today sharing two more anti-vaccine posts. The first one is the NVIC version of the flawed Pascal’s Wager:

HIH 23 NVIC unvaccinate memeAnd the second one is information which has already been debunked, the paper being removed for investigation:

HIH 24 MMR autism fraud
Update September 2 2014

Traynor posts another anti-vaccine meme from the premier US anti-vaccination outfit, NVIC:

HIH 25 NVIC post question vaccines

Update October 14 2014

Traynor posts this offensive, conspiracy-driven, factually inaccurate anti-vaccine meme from conspiracy beacon, The Liberty Beacon:

HIH 30 Gardasil murders

Posted in anti-vaccination dishonesty, australian vaccination network, AVN, chiropractic, Immunisation, meryl dorey, skeptic, stop the australian vaccination network | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Anti-vaccine chiropractor Tim Shakespeare to co-present with anti-vaccine legend at anti-vaccine chiropractic seminar

Tim Shakespeare of Healing Wave Chiropractic, in NSW, was once a board member of the Chiropractors’ Association of Australia NSW chapter. That was until the CAA NSW took proper notice of his arrogant public anti-vaccinationism, and his bragging about secretly entering public hospitals to perform his voodoo without the permission of any treating practitioners or other hospital staff.

This image hammered the final nail in his coffin. It’s one of my favourite all time images. He even tagged me in it:

Shakes 59 RH with DeMossBecause vaccines are exactly the same as heroin. “Brett Hill…likes this”.

Anyway, not one to take any notice of being punted from the CAA NSW board, or warnings from the CAA National board to stay away from anti-vaccinationists, Shakespeare has been seen commenting on the page of the ugly anti-vaccination pressure group, the Australian Vaccination Skeptics Network, as well as posting a link to his own blog on the AVN page. This is from October 2013:

Shakes 69 AVN page re SunriseWhilst this one is from January 2014:

Shakes 71 AVN post HCCC blog share“Blogosaurus”. Oooookay. I’m saying nothing. I know what you’re all thinking.

Anyway, what got me to including Shakespeare again was something I noticed today. He is giving a talk in one week with renowned US anti-vaccinationst Tim O’Shea. Yes, the same Tim O’Shea who used to provide immunisation training CPD points for Australian chiropractors, as organised by the CAA, until it was pointed out to the community, when it was then promptly dropped (excellent work from Amy Corderoy). And the organisation who is holding the seminar is none other than the Dead Chiropractic Society, run by the notoriously deranged anti-vaccinationist, chemtrail-hating, David Icke-citing, germ theory denying, NWO soft-kill and depopulation espousing Billy DeMoss:

Shakes 79 DCS O'Shea DeMossBilly DeMoss has also recently hosted CAA luminaries such as Jennifer and Simon Floreani (pictured with Andrew Wakefield), and Laurence Tham. I’m wondering when President Tassell’s words of warning will ever ring true?

I’d love to watch the talk, but, I’m not paying money. Maybe the CAA will watch it, and then act in accordance with its previous threats. It hasn’t yet.


Posted in anti-vaccination dishonesty, australian vaccination network, AVN, chiropractic, skeptic, stop the australian vaccination network | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 7 Comments

Public Apology from Mr Phillip Ebrall

Earlier this year a public apology was meant to be published in the Chiropractic Journal of Australia, regarding comments made in an editorial by Mr Phillip Ebrall. The comments, and others, can be found in my post from December 2013:  The Phillip Ebrall Monologues: chiropractor at large.

The apology was never printed because the CJA went into hibernation. The defamatory comments were also printed in The Australian Chiropractor, the magazine of the Chiropractors’ Association of Australia. The public apology was not published there either.

On request, Mr Ebrall (Former Assistant Editor, CJA) has kindly provided us with a copy of his apology:


The editorial of December 2013 (Chiropr J Aust 43) used the descriptors ‘fringe-dwellers’ and ‘scum ring’ to describe what has unfortunately been taken as the entirety of one particular group. As the author of those comments I unhesitatingly withdraw them and apologise for any upset this may have caused.

It must be appreciated that politically motivated sub-groups do exist however I fully accept it is not appropriate to use an opinion piece of writing to make reference to these in any way, let alone in a manner that may be interpreted differently than intended.

I would welcome constructive dialogue with every person who respects evidence-influenced practice with a view to working more positively and cooperatively together to improve our mutual understanding.

Phillip Ebrall
Former Assistant Editor, CJA

[Received June 26 2014]

Screenshot of apology:

Ebrall 27 apology June 26 2014

Posted in chiropractic, skeptic | Tagged , , , , , | 3 Comments

Anti-vaccine chiropractors redux 3

Since August 8 2013 chiropractors in Australia have been banned from posting anti-vaccine misinformation, well, anywhere. Period.

I’m not sure how much the Chiropractic Board of Australia has done about its anti-vaccine chiropractors: we only hear rumours. We don’t see any published evidence of action. I’d like to see some numbers, names, and some content.

Tom Dawson runs a manipulation business called Wellbeing Hawthorn. He featured in my original Anti-vaccine chiropractors series as number 3.

Then, when I visited his page in November 2013, I noticed another anti-vaccine post linking vaccines and autism. I wrote about that one, here. He removed that anti-vaccine post, dated November 27 2013.

So, he posted anti-vaccine misinformation after being told to stop, by the CBA; and, he posted more anti-vaccine misinformation after I posted about his anti-vaccination misinformation in my original series. Maybe it’s Oppositional Defiant Disorder? That steenking board won’t tell ME what to do…

But, silly me. I missed another of his posts. It was made on November 16 2013, and he still hasn’t removed it.

This is a man who posts incredulous anti-vaccine memes. This man encourages his clients to “investigate” their recommended vaccines. A man who said, last year:

Here come the medical Nazi’s, once they get the right to inject your child with things you don’t want them to, next they will remove your rights to choose for other things. Medical fundamentalism is no better than any other.

and dishonestly, and callously:

I don’t hear about unvaccinated kids dying of these diseases

 All of the children getting these diseases, dying from them and/or featured in the media HAVE BEEN VACCINATED

That’s some encouragement, right there.

Dawson 8 Gardasil post scamSo, over to you, once again, CBA.

Posted in anti-vaccination dishonesty, chiropractic, skeptic, stop the australian vaccination network | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

The Anti-Vaccination Network’s talk at the Healthy Lifestyle Expo


In this post Meryl Dorey’s Expo talk gets eaten alive by an immunologist. Please click through and see the demolition by someone who really knows what he’s talking about. You won’t regret it…

Originally posted on The LymphoSite:

Yes, She Actually Said That

On the 25th of May 2014, the spokesperson for the Australian Vaccination Skeptics Network (AVSN, formerly the Australian Vaccination Network), Meryl Dorey presented a talk, Vaccinations – Do They Really Save Lives? at the Healthy Lifestyle (You Can Heal Yourself) Expo in Caloundra, Queensland.

If you’re familiar with the AVSN, you know they’re an anti-vaccine group that do not provide reliable information on vaccines, and in fact disseminate misleading, misrepresented and incorrect information about vaccination which engenders fear and alarm, according to the public statement the New South Wales Health Care Complaints Commission put out about them.

You may of heard of their spokesperson and public officer, Meryl Dorey, who has no qualifications in immunology, microbiology, medicine or vaccinology and who for over a decade has been the major voice behind most of the incorrect information  put out by the group. This talk was no exception.

In reading…

View original 2,871 more words

Posted in anti-vaccination dishonesty, australian vaccination network, AVN, meryl dorey, stop the australian vaccination network, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Meryl Dorey again repeats ‘vaccines cause Shaken Baby Syndrome’ lie at Queensland Expo

Many people have written before about what Orac calls The vilest antivaccine lie that won’t die: Shaken baby syndrome as “vaccine injury”For a greater understanding of this particularly nasty anti-vaccine lie, I highly recommend reading the Orac post.

Another person who has been on top of the vaccines cause SBS lie, longer than anyone would care to be aware of, such is its repugnance, is Peter Bowditch.

Back in 1997 a thug by the name of Alan Yurko killed his girlfriend’s 10 week old son. After being acquitted of murder, due to sloppy morgue practices, Yurko went down for manslaughter. Peter Bowditch has a very thorough timeline of events on his site.

I want to note some of the injuries listed in the post-mortem of the slaughtered baby. From Peter’s site:

Note – the baby had been crying for a few days before the father held it by its feet and hit it.

Post-Mortem Findings included minor contusions of both temporal areas of the head, small ecchymosis of the right lower eyelid, fresh subdural hemorrhages of the right and left cerebral hemispheres and at base of brain and some areas of spinal cord, and retinal bleeding. The brain was grossly edematous. In addition there were several old, healing fractures of the 5th, 6th, 7th and 10th ribs, all posterior and on the left.

To cut a long story short, chiropractic organisations and anti-vaccine activists swung in behind Yurko, where they remain to this day. As Peter Bowditch notes, Yurko was labeled a “hero” by the International Chiropractors Association’s Pediatric Council. You read that right. And one of the main medical advocates for the baby slaughterer was one Harold Buttram (remember that bit).

So, take into account the injuries suffered by that 10 week old baby; remember that the injuries he sustained (some whilst being hung upside down by his feet, and struck) led him to be the subject of a post-mortem; and now remind yourselves of what Meryl Dorey and her husband Ken Dorey said on January 7 2001, on the AVN Yahoo! Group:

Dear Barbara,

I just read this out to my husband who is great with catch phrases and he suggests – Shaken Maybe Syndrome. I like Shaken from the inside too – both are good. And a great thought – you are right – sound bites have it. And as my 16 year old niece would say – that bites!

Take care,


AVN 6808 Dorey shaken maybe syndrome Yahoo messageYou also read that right. In the Dorey household it is okay to sit around thinking up glib “catch phrases”, which have “bite”, to defend baby killers.

With all of this in mind I want you to read the following transcript, taken from Dorey’s appearance yesterday at the You Can Heal Yourself Expo, on Queensland’s Sunshine Coast. The organisers defended Dorey’s right to be at the Expo, and staunchly defended Dorey’s right to give a presentation. Media also gave Dorey free plugs. The organisers led people to believe that the HCCC’s Public Health Warning against the Australian Vaccination-Skeptics Network would be on display. It wasn’t.

Read this astonishing transcript for yourself and then judge the actions of the organisers of the Expo:

Questioner: Yeah hi I was wondering with the SIDS I’ve heard that a lot of fathers and sometimes mothers have been jailed for I guess being said that they caused the deaths from shaking while their babies were sleeping or something, because the vaccinations actually cause bruises as well as the instant death. Do you have any statistics on that or something?

Meryl: I don’t have statistics but there is a book we carry it  it’s called Sudden Infant Death I can never remember the whole name it’s quite long it’s written by Harold Buttram who’s an MD, a GP who has been studying this for a long time and he has actually engaged an engineer of some kind, a mechanical engineer I think to test what sort of force is needed to shake a baby in order to cause brain damage and bleeding behind the eyes which are basically the symptoms they look at in shaken baby, and it is impossible according to this expert, it is impossible to shake a baby hard enough to cause that sort of damage without breaking their neck. I mean even if you hold the baby’s head and body at the same time and shake them, the neck has to break. So shaken baby syndrome again like SIDS, is a waste basket. It is a way of blaming the family for what may have been caused by the medical community. And bleeding behind the eyes, retinal bleeding is something that has been known to follow vaccination, it has been known to follow hypoxia or lack of oxygen. There are so many things that can cause that symptom and um, in Australia there is a doctor by the name of Archie K who also put a lot of those symptoms they’re looking at with shaken baby down to lack of vitamin C, he even believed that vaccinations caused uh, ah a deficit of vitamin C and that those would cause the bruising and the broken bones that a lot of people were seeing in this babies as well. Uh yeah, shaken baby syndrome is being used, so is Munchausen’s Syndrome by Proxy.

And she wonders why reasonable people will not debate her. Sometimes there are just no words.

Update 1 hour later:

This is precisely the problem with allowing someone to lie their face off at vulnerable parents:

AVN 6809 Zaiga Virsis never vaccinating due to Dorey talk at Expo


I want to give a huge shout out to many people who contributed to this post: Of course, Peter Bowditch, who has been all over this for years; the two ninjas who politely attended the Expo and made it possible to see the above words; and the OTTER who transcribed like a now wounded sea mammal.

Posted in abuse, anti-vaccination dishonesty, australian vaccination network, AVN, Immunisation, meryl dorey, stop the australian vaccination network | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 23 Comments